• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

My TechDecisions

  • Best of Tech Decisions
  • Topics
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Mobility
    • Unified Communications
    • IT Infrastructure
    • Network Security
    • Physical Security
    • Facility
    • Compliance
  • RFP Resources
  • Resources
  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Project of the Week
  • About Us
    SEARCH
Network Security

Passcodes Are Protected By the Law – Sort Of

Citing a case from Florida, Naked Security delves into the Fifth Amendment, and how legal cases involving passcodes are affected.

November 20, 2018 Jessica Messier Leave a Comment

According to Naked Security, passcodes are now being spun into the Fifth Amendment, which protects U.S. citizens from being held for committing a crime, unless they have been indicted correctly by police.

The latest case seen in the Florida Court of Appeals demonstrates how it’s no longer enough for police to have a “reasonable certainty” that a device is able to be unlocked by a person targeted by the order; this means that previously, the government only had to show that a defendant knew a password. Instead, now, police need to know that a device involved in a case has “specific evidence needed to prosecute the case.”

In the recent Florida case – where a teenager drove under the influence of alcohol, got into an accident, killed one of their passengers, and police requested that they unlock their phone for the corresponding legal case – police did not prove that there was evidence on the involved device to assist in the trial. Because of this, the trial court could not find that the information on the device was “already known to the state,” and within the “forgone conclusion” exception.

“Regardless of the ‘foregone conclusion’ standard, producing a passcode is testimonial and has the potential to harm the defendant, just like any other Fifth Amendment violation would,” the Florida court said, according to Naked Security. “It’s not as if the passcode itself does anything for the government. What it’s really after is what lies beyond that passcode: information it can use as evidence against the defendant who’s being compelled to produce it.”

What happened in Florida, and what it means:

Based on these findings, the Florida Court of Appeals quashed the court’s order for the defendant, Naked Security said. According to court documents,

“below and on appeal, the state’s argument has incorrectly focused on the passcode as the target of the foregone conclusion exception rather than the data shielded by the passcode, arguing that “because the State has established the existence of the … evidence on the Petitioner’s cell phone, and that he can access the content of his phone,” the compelled search was acceptable.”

Additionally, Naked Security said that these “grabs for passcodes” in this case “amount to phishing expeditions.” “Without reasonable particularity as to the documents sought behind the passcode wall, the facts of this case “plainly fall outside” of the foregone conclusion exception and amount to a mere fishing expedition,” according to the court documents.

However, while this happened to be the case for Florida, Naked Security says that state courts ultimately can’t change how passcode-disclosure/Fifth Amendment cases are decided nationally. As a result, decision makers might consider researching the passcode –related laws in their state, especially if an employee, business or institution as a whole runs into a similar legal snag.

If you enjoyed this article and want to receive more valuable industry content like this, click here to sign up for our digital newsletters!

Tagged With: Cyber Security, Legal

Related Content:

  • Progress MOVEit vulnerability Progress Software Urges Further Action to Prevent MOVEit…
  • June 2023 Patch Tuesday. Patch Tuesday, June 2023 Patch Tuesday: Exchange Server, SharePoint, PGM
  • Fortinet Vulnerability, Fortigate Patch FortiGate SSL-VPN Devices Immediately
  • Barracuda ESG Barracuda: Replace Compromised ESG Appliances Immediately

Free downloadable guide you may like:

  • Download TechDecisions' Blueprint Series report on Security Awareness now!Blueprint Series: Why Your Security Awareness Program is Probably Falling Short

    Learn about the evolution of phishing attacks and best practices for security awareness programs to ensure your organization is properly prepared to defend against them in this report from TechDecisions' Blueprint Series.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get the FREE Tech Decisions eNewsletter

Sign up Today!

Latest Downloads

Download TechDecisions' Blueprint Series report on Security Awareness now!
Blueprint Series: Why Your Security Awareness Program is Probably Falling Short

Learn about the evolution of phishing attacks and best practices for security awareness programs to ensure your organization is properly prepared t...

Workplace Collaboration Tools for Corporate Spaces
Workplace Collaboration Tools for Corporate Spaces

From lobbies and shared spaces to conference rooms and multipurpose facilities, you need high-performing AV technology to effectively share informa...

ChatGPT, generative AI, enterprise, workplace
Blueprint Series: ChatGPT and Generative AI in the Workplace

This latest release of the TechDecisions Blueprint Series explores the new phenomenon of tools such as ChatGPT and how IT leaders should go about d...

View All Downloads

Would you like your latest project featured on TechDecisions as Project of the Week?

Apply Today!
Sharp Microsoft Collaboration HQ Logo

Learn More About the
Windows Collaboration Display

More from Our Sister Publications

Get the latest news about AV integrators and Security installers from our sister publications:

Commercial IntegratorSecurity Sales

AV-iQ

Footer

TechDecisions

  • Home
  • Welcome to TechDecisions
  • Subscribe to the Newsletter
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Comment Guidelines
  • RSS Feeds
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

Free Technology Guides

FREE Downloadable resources from TechDecisions provide timely insight into the issues that IT, A/V, and Security end-users, managers, and decision makers are facing in commercial, corporate, education, institutional, and other vertical markets

View all Guides
TD Project of the Week

Get your latest project featured on TechDecisions Project of the Week. Submit your work once and it will be eligible for all upcoming weeks.

Enter Today!
Emerald Logo
ABOUTCAREERSAUTHORIZED SERVICE PROVIDERSDO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATIONTERMS OF USEPRIVACY POLICY

© 2023 Emerald X, LLC. All rights reserved.