Tell Us About Your IoT/Collaboration Meeting Room Plans for 2021 & You Could Win a 60" Display! 
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

My TechDecisions

  • COVID-19 Update
  • Best of Tech Decisions
  • Topics
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Mobility
    • Unified Communications
    • IT Infrastructure
    • Network Security
    • Physical Security
    • Facility
    • Compliance
  • RFP Resources
  • Downloads
  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Project of the Week
  • About Us
    SEARCH
IT Infrastructure, News

Is the Net Neutrality Repeal Saving Consumers Billions?

The Trump Administration claims the net neutrality repeal will save consumers lots of money, but the facts aren’t adding up.

March 11, 2020 Jessica Messier Leave a Comment

5G

According to Ars Technica, the Trump Administration is using pseudo-economics to prove that eliminating consumer-protection rules has boosted consumers’ income by billions of dollars.

Last month, the Trump Administration released a report stating that its ‘Restoring Internet Freedom’ order, also known as the repeal of net neutrality rules a few years back, will “increase real incomes by more than $50 billion per year and consumer welfare by almost $40 billion per year,” Ars Technica says.

The Trump Administration turns to a 2008 study on digital subscriber line sharing to back its boost in income claims. “Previous research shows that vertical pricing restrictions in broadband significantly reduce the quantity and quality of services received by broadband consumers…” Looking at “open access” restrictions applied to Digital Subscriber Line service, but not Cable Modem access for three years, the Digital Subscriber Line service subscriptions grew more than 30 percent relative to the trend, and Cable Modem subscriptions “increased slightly.” Additionally, the average revenue per Digital Subscriber Line fell across those three years, and the average revenue per Cable Modem subscriber was constant.

The Trump Administration said that by applying similar tactics from these findings to internet service providers in the years 2017-2027, i.e. removing vertical pricing regulations, its “Restoring Internet Freedom” order will increase real incomes tens of billions of dollars per year.

The Truth About These Alternative Facts

Ars Technica suggests that it’s not clear how that 2008 study is applicable to the effects resulting from the administration’s repeal of net neutrality. The “net neutrality rules were hardly similar to the old DSL line-sharing requirements. The line-sharing rules let DSL Internet providers offer service over the phone lines controlled by incumbent telephone companies, letting consumers choose from many DSL providers instead of just one.”

On top of that, unlike line sharing, the net neutrality rules don’t address the “competition problem” that forces consumers to choose between one or two high-speed providers, Ars Technica says. “Instead, the rules prohibited certain kinds of anti-consumer behavior that [internet service providers] are more likely to pursue when they have virtual monopolies over Internet access,” like paid prioritization and vague explanations about pricing to consumers.

Finally, the White House failed to point to the effects that resulted from the years of net neutrality rules, including an increase of broadband speed. Plus, broadband networks grew at the same rate before and after the net neutrality repeal. As a result, “If anything, the evidence points to regulation and deregulation having little effect on broadband growth,” Ars Technica says.

As a result, it appears that the Trump Administration’s claimed success isn’t what it appears to be. Harold Feld, a broadband-industry expert says that it’s common practice for administrations to “pseudo-economics” to show how their policies are positively impacting consumers when they’re really not. “One of the fun things about how folks use pseudo-economics in public policy is that you can use it to justify all kinds of price gouging and other consumer harms as ‘efficiencies’ and then make up a model that produces some suitably impressive number of ‘consumer surplus’ that makes it all seem OK,” he told Ars Technica.

Tagged With: Internet

Related Content:

  • office building energy management tips for IT departments Office Building Energy Management Tips for IT Departments
  • Hospital Security Tech is Keeping COVID Vaccines Secure
  • ServiceNow Vaccine Management ServiceNow Announces COVID-19 Vaccine Management Solution
  • Google Vulnerability Researchers Google: North Korean Actors Targeting Vulnerability Researchers

Free downloadable guide you may like:

  • Top 9 Reasons Enterprise IT Leaders Are Moving Their Video Surveillance to the Eagle Eye Cloud

    Working in IT has enough challenges without adding in the complications of surveillance video. Things like total cost of maintenance, how the VMA manages bandwidth, what cameras are supported, what level of cybersecurity is provided, and what integrations are available to use are important factors IT managers have to think about when assessing a video […]

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get the FREE Tech Decisions eNewsletter

Sign up Today!

Latest Downloads

9 Technology Products to Help Combat COVID-19 Spread in the Workplace

As the Coronavirus continues on and leads us further into uncertainty, the question remains, “when do we return to the office?” For some the answer...

Top 9 Reasons Enterprise IT Leaders Are Moving Their Video Surveillance to the Eagle Eye Cloud

Working in IT has enough challenges without adding in the complications of surveillance video. Things like total cost of maintenance, how the VMA m...

Using Live Chats and Chatbots to Increase Customer Engagement

There's a lot to consider when building out a chatbot experience to ensure that it delivers a seamless experience and meet your business goals.

View All Downloads

Would you like your latest project featured on TechDecisions as Project of the Week?

Apply Today!
Sharp Microsoft Collaboration HQ Logo

Learn More About the
Windows Collaboration Display

More from Our Sister Publications

Get the latest news about AV integrators and Security installers from our sister publications:

Commercial IntegratorSecurity Sales

Footer

TechDecisions

  • Home
  • Welcome to TechDecisions
  • Subscribe to the Newsletter
  • Contact Us
  • Media Solutions & Advertising
  • Comment Guidelines
  • RSS Feeds
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

Free Technology Guides

FREE Downloadable resources from TechDecisions provide timely insight into the issues that IT, A/V, and Security end-users, managers, and decision makers are facing in commercial, corporate, education, institutional, and other vertical markets

View all Guides
TD Project of the Week

Get your latest project featured on TechDecisions Project of the Week. Submit your work once and it will be eligible for all upcoming weeks.

Enter Today!

© 2021 Emerald X, LLC. All rights reserved.